Research shows dandruff affects up to 50% of the global population at some point. A leading dermatologist says dandruff vs. dry scalp "are often confused, but they require different approaches."
Dandruff vs. Dry Scalp: An Expert Doctor Explains the Difference
Published on Jan. 16, 2025
If you’re dealing with persistent flakes and perhaps some itchiness, you might be questioning whether the cause is dandruff vs. dry scalp—and, most importantly, how to get rid of it.
“Dandruff is a common scalp condition that causes flaking and itching of the scalp skin,” explains Susan Massick, MD, a board-certified dermatologist at the Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center. It’s a mild form of seborrheic dermatitis, which is a chronic inflammatory skin condition. On the other hand, Dr. Massick defines dry scalp as “dry skin related to a loss of moisture, leading to flaking and itching.” Similar to the skin on the rest of your body, your scalp can become flaky when it dries out.
“Dandruff and dry scalp are often confused, but they require different approaches,” Dr. Massick says. If over-the-counter treatments aren’t effective or if your scalp becomes red, painful, or excessively scaly, it’s time to consult a dermatologist. They can evaluate your symptoms and develop a personalized treatment plan for you.
Ahead, Dr. Massick unpacks the key differences between dandruff vs. dry scalp and offers expert tips to treat and prevent both conditions.
Symptoms of dandruff
- Flaking: White or yellowish flakes of skin that appear on the scalp, hair, shoulders, or clothing.
- Itching: Persistent itching of the scalp, which can be mild to severe.
- Scalp irritation: A sensation of tightness or discomfort on the scalp.
- Greasy or oily scalp: The scalp may feel oily due to an overproduction of sebum, which can exacerbate dandruff.
- Redness: Inflamed or red patches on the scalp, often due to irritation or scratching.
- Scaly patches: Some people may notice scaly or crusty patches on the scalp, especially with more severe forms of dandruff.
Symptoms of dry scalp
- Flaking: Small, dry, white flakes of skin that may fall from the scalp. These flakes are usually finer and less oily compared to dandruff.
- Itching: Persistent or occasional itching due to dryness and a lack of moisture in the scalp.
- Tightness: A sensation of tightness or discomfort, often described as feeling like the skin is stretched.
- Dryness: The scalp feels dry to the touch and may lack natural oils or moisture.
- Irritation: The scalp may feel sensitive or irritated, especially after using certain hair products or during exposure to dry or cold weather.
- Lack of oiliness: Unlike dandruff, dry scalp is associated with a lack of natural oils, making the scalp feel parched rather than greasy.
Dandruff vs dry scalp: How to tell the difference
The appearance of the flakes can help distinguish between dandruff and a dry scalp. For dandruff, “Skin flakes may be larger plaques of yellowish scale, often associated with an oily scalp with some degree of redness/irritation from inflammation,” explains Dr. Massick. In contrast, with a dry scalp, “Skin looks dry with small white flakes and no apparent redness or inflammation.”
What causes dandruff and dry scalp?
Although both dandruff and dry scalp share symptoms like flakiness and itching, their root causes are different. Dr. Massick shares what contributes to dandruff and dry scalp:
Dandruff causes
Dandruff or seborrheic dermatitis, is a chronic inflammatory skin condition with no known cure. Although it primarily affects the scalp, it can also appear on areas like the face (around the nostrils, between the brows, and in or around the ears) and the central chest. Common causes of dandruff include:
- Overgrowth of Malassezia yeast: This naturally occurring yeast on the skin can grow excessively, leading to inflammation, irritation, and flakiness.
- Excess oil production: An oily scalp creates the perfect environment for dandruff to develop.
- Stress: High stress levels can weaken the skin’s defenses, worsening dandruff symptoms.
- Weather changes: Cold, dry weather or sudden temperature shifts can trigger dandruff flare-ups.
Dry scalp causes
- Loss of natural oils: Over-washing your hair or using harsh shampoos and styling products can strip the scalp of its natural moisture, leading to dryness.
- Environmental factors: Exposure to cold temperatures and low-humidity winter air can sap moisture from your scalp, leaving it dry and flaky.
- Underlying skin conditions: Issues like eczema or psoriasis can exacerbate scalp dryness, causing irritation and discomfort.
Can you have both dandruff and dry scalp?
Dr. Massick confirms: “Yes, it’s possible to have both.” While dandruff and dry scalp are often confused due to similar symptoms like flaking and itchiness, they can coexist. This means that someone can experience the fungal imbalance alongside dehydration of the scalp, leading to more pronounced and persistent symptoms.
How to treat dandruff
Dr. Massick recommends the following effective dandruff treatments and tips to help you regain a flake-free scalp:
Medicated shampoos
“Use medicated shampoos with ingredients such as selenium sulfide, zinc pyrithione, ketoconazole, salicylic acid, or even the old-school coal tar shampoos,” advises Dr. Massick. These ingredients target dandruff by reducing flaking, oil buildup, and inflammation. To get the most benefit:
- Apply the shampoo directly to your scalp.
- Leave it on for five to 10 minutes before rinsing thoroughly. (In some cases, just 30 seconds to a minute will be enough time to deliver relief.)
- Use medicated shampoos two to three times per week for best results.
While many medicated shampoos are available over-the-counter, stronger formulations may require a prescription from your healthcare provider.
Consistent hair washing
A regular hair-washing routine helps control oil buildup, one of the main contributors to dandruff. However, Dr. Massick cautions against overwashing, as it can deplete your scalp’s natural oils and lead to dryness and irritation. Curious about the right balance? Read here’s how often you really should be washing your hair.
How to treat dry scalp
Dr. Massick suggests these remedies for treating a dry scalp:
- Use a gentle, moisturizing shampoo and conditioner: Avoid products that strip your scalp of its natural oils. Washing your scalp daily isn’t necessary and can lead to further dryness. Instead, cleanse as needed to maintain hydration.
- Avoid harsh, alcohol-based styling products: “If it stings, skip it,” says Dr. Massick. Instead, choose soothing, nourishing products designed to protect your scalp. For recommendations, consult your dermatologist to find options that work best for you.
How to prevent dandruff
Dr. Massick discusses the importance of regularly using an anti-dandruff shampoo, even after symptoms have subsided, to maintain control and prevent recurrence. Be mindful of potential triggers, such as stress, seasonal changes, dry or cold weather, and certain hair products, as these can cause flare-ups. Proactive care and consistency are key to keeping dandruff at bay.
How to prevent dry scalp
Preventing dry scalp starts with a thoughtful hair care routine that protects its natural oils. Dr. Massick advises limiting hair washing and minimizing the use of heat styling tools, which can dry out the scalp. Regularly using hydrating conditioners helps lock in essential moisture, while running a humidifier at home combats the drying effects of indoor heating, keeping your scalp healthy and comfortable year-round.
When to see a doctor
If over-the-counter treatments don’t improve your dandruff or dry scalp symptoms after a few weeks, it’s time to see a doctor. Persistent itching, redness, or flaking that disrupts your daily life, as well as signs of infection such as sores or swelling, also warrant professional evaluation. You can start with your primary care provider (PCP) for an initial assessment and treatment recommendations. However, if the condition is severe, recurring, or unresponsive to treatment, consulting a dermatologist is ideal. Dermatologists specialize in skin and scalp conditions and can provide targeted therapies to address the root cause and bring relief.
About the expert:
Susan Massick, MD, is a board-certified dermatologist at the Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center with over 20 years of experience in dermatology. She serves on the editorial committee of the national Women’s Dermatologic Society and is also an associate professor of internal medicine, where she trains the next generation of aspiring dermatologists.
For daily wellness updates, subscribe to The Healthy by Reader’s Digest newsletter and follow The Healthy on Facebook and Instagram. Keep reading:
